Customer reviews
Verified customer feedback across our cartons. Read real experiences before you choose your next order.
Not sure
This was my first carton of the Marlboro reds. The red pack was fine, but the second pack tasted older.
Not sure
This was my first carton of these red shorts. The reds are stronger than I expected, and not in a good way. It is okay for the price.
Mixed bag
Picked up the hard box at the counter and smoked a pack before deciding. The filter is a little soft, and the last third gets harsh. The pack was sealed, but the date code was older than I hoped. It is okay for the price.
Average
The price is okay, but the shipping took longer than the estimate. Shipping took longer than the estimate. The reds are stronger than I expected, and not in a good way.
Hit or miss
Ordered these Newport shorts to see what the hype was about. They smoke fine, nothing special. The burn is a little uneven. The carton was not short, but it was not packed very well.
Mixed bag
Draw is tight.
Not sure
Got this red pack in the mail and gave them a few days before reviewing. The cigs are smokeable, but I would not call them my first choice. One pack was short; the rest were fine.
Middle of the road
Ordered the reds to see what the hype was about. The red pack was fine, but the second pack tasted older. The carton was sealed, but a couple of packs were loose in the box.
Hit or miss
They smoke fine, nothing special. The burn is a little uneven.
Hit or miss
One pack was short; the rest were fine. The carton was not short, but it was not packed very well.
Hit or miss
The pack was sealed, but the date code was older than I hoped. The packaging was plain, which is fine, but the box was beat up. Maybe next carton will be better.
Fine
The filter is a little soft, and the last third gets harsh. The date code was older than I would like. Might try once more.
Okay
This was my first carton of the hard box. The ash falls off on its own, which gets annoying. Would not go out of my way for them.
Mixed bag
Ordered the menthol shorts to see what the hype was about. The menthol is there, but it fades before the cig is done. Would not go out of my way for them.
Not sure
Date code was old.
Could be better
The cigs are smokeable, but I would not call them my first choice. The smoke is a little hot on the back of my throat. Might try once more.
Mixed bag
This was my first carton of the green pack. The ash falls off on its own, which gets annoying. The carton was sealed, but a couple of packs were loose in the box. I have had worse.
Okay
The flavor is close, but it has a slight chemical note.
Not sure
The reds are stronger than I expected, and not in a good way.
Could be better
Ordered the reds to see what the hype was about. The flavor is there, but the filter feels cheap. The box was a little dented, but the packs were still sealed.
Not sure
The smoke is a little hot on the back of my throat. The date code was older than I would like. Would not go out of my way for them.
Okay
This was my first carton of the green pack. The paper burns a little fast for my taste. Might try once more.
Middle of the road
The carton was okay for the price, but not a rebuy for me. The carton was not short, but it was not packed very well. The filter is a little soft, and the last third gets harsh. It is okay for the price.
Average
Burns fast.
Mixed bag
Half the packs were good, one was stale and harsh. The box was a little dented, but the packs were still sealed. Maybe next carton will be better.
Could be better
This was my first carton of these hard whites. The flavor is there, but the filter feels cheap. The carton was not short, but it was not packed very well.
Fine
The pack was sealed, but the date code was older than I hoped. The carton was okay, but one pack was loose.
Fine
One pack was short; the rest were fine. Could be better.
Average
Nothing special.
Hit or miss
The burn is fast, so a pack does not last long. Would not go out of my way for them.
Okay
This was my first carton of the Marlboro reds. The red pack was fine, but the second pack tasted older. Might try once more.
Hit or miss
This was my first carton of the menthol shorts. The cigs are smokeable, but I would not call them my first choice. It is okay for the price.
Okay
Picked up these long Newports at the counter and smoked a pack before deciding. The long pack is fine, but the menthol is weaker than the shorts.
Okay
Meh.
Mixed bag
Fine for the price.